Gwyneth Paltrow’s blasted for promoting ‘leanest liveable weight’ goal

Scientists are not happy with Gwyneth (again)

Gwyneth Paltrow

by William Marriott |
Updated on

An article on Gwyneth Paltrow's wellness advice website Goop encouraging readers to try and reach their "leanest liveable weight" has been called "dangerous" by scientists.

They say the message is open to problematic interpretation and could encourage eating disorders like anorexia in young, susceptible girls.

The article, titled "Busting Diet Myths", includes an interview with Dr Traci Mann, in which she says people should attempt to be at their lowest "set range."

She describes this as a weight which a generally healthy person would be able to maintain.

However, the article has now been blasted by Dr Giles Yeo, from Cambridge University, who says the article is "irresponsbile" as it suggests people should be "as skinny as possible without dying."

CHECK OUT the most incredible celebrity image transformations

Gallery

Celebrity transformations slider with cover pic

celebrity transformations1 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Shutterstock

Swipe through to see the most amazing celebrity transformations of all time...

Little Mix2 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Shutterstock

Little Mix, then

Perrie Edwards, Leigh-Anne Pinnock, Jesy Nelson and Jade Thirlwall looked very young in 2011 after winning The X Factor. To be fair, they were all teenagers at the time!

Little Mix, now3 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Shutterstock

Little Mix, now

Now the biggest girl band on the planet, the girls look fantastic!

Calvin Harris4 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Shutterstock

Calvin Harris, then

Scottish DJ Calvin Harris pictured here in 2009. Sorry Calvin, but we're not sure that look would be Acceptable In The 80s - OR now.

Calvin Harris5 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Shutterstock

Calvin Harris, now

The 'One Kiss' hit-maker transformed into an A-list hunk, and has dated the likes of Taylor Swift and Rita Ora. Twit twoo!

Cheryl, then6 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Shutterstock

Cheryl, then

Girls Aloud singer Cheryl was just a fresh-faced teenager when she auditioned for Popstars: The Rivals in 2002.

Cheryl, now7 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Shutterstock

Cheryl, now

She's now an on-trend and super-glamorous mum-of-one, even walking the red carpet at a London Fashion Week show.

Justin Bieber8 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Shutterstock

Justin Bieber, then

Little Justin Bieber was just a Baby when he burst onto the scene in 2009...

Justin Bieber, now9 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Shutterstock

Justin Bieber, now

These days, he's of course grown up - but he looks pretty much the same! Apart from the fact that he no longer has the signature Bieber hairstyle, of course.

Rihanna, then10 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Shutterstock

Rihanna, then

A young Rihanna in 2005...

Rihanna, now11 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Shutterstock

Rihanna, now

The still cheeky Fenty grin is still there, and Rihanna continues to defy the aging process.

Matthew Lewis, then12 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Shutterstock

Matthew Lewis, then

Harry Potter star Matthew Lewis starred in the film series as Neville Longbottom from 2001 to the last film in 2011, here pictured in 2004 at the Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban premiere.

Matthew Lewis, now13 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Shutterstock

Matthew Lewis, now

Matthew grew up into such a good-looking chap that the makeup department on the Potter films had to try and make him less attractive in the later films, even spawning the phrase 'Longbottomed'.

Miley Cyrus, then14 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Shutterstock

Miley Cyrus, then

Miley Cyrus in her Hannah Montana days...

Miley Cyrus, now15 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Shutterstock

Miley Cyrus, now

She may have gone through various transformations, but Miley is still recognisable.

Gareth Gates, then16 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Shutterstock

Gareth Gates, then

Pop Idol contestant Gareth Gates on the show back in 2001...

Gareth Gates17 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Instagram

Gareth Gates, now

Here in 2017, he showing off his muscular physique alongside his girlfriend Faye Brookes.

Katy Perry, then18 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Shutterstock

Katy Perry, then

Katy Perry rocking long black hair in 2004...

Katy Perry, now19 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Shutterstock

Katy Perry, now

And showing off her shorter, blonde pixie cut in 2017.

Chris Pratt, then20 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Getty Images

Chris Pratt, then

Jurassic Park actor Chris Pratt back in 2008...

Chris Pratt, now21 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Getty Images

Chris Pratt, now

Shed the pounds and now has a slimmer physique.

Kylie Jenner22 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Getty Images

Kylie Jenner, then

A fresh faced Kylie Jenner in 2008...

Kylie Jenner, now23 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Getty Images

Kylie Jenner, now

Now rocking a platinum blonde 'do at the age of 21 in November 2018.

Zac Efron, then24 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Getty Images

Zac Efron, then

Zac Efron in his High School Musical days back in 2007...

Zac Efron, now25 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Getty Images

Zac Efron

10 years later, he was looking incredibly dapper at the Australian premiere for The Greatest Showman in 2017 - even sporting a 'tache.

Justin Timberlake, then26 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Getty Images

Justin Timberlake, then

JT rocking his epic tight curls with frosted tips back in 2000...

Justin Timberlake, now27 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Getty Images

Justin Timberlake, now

He's so much more grown-up in September 2018 whilst performing in Las Vegas.

Johnny Vegas28 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Shutterstock

Johnny Vegas, then

TV personality Johnny Vegas, real name Michael Pennington, is well known for his larger frame.

Johnny Vegas, now29 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Twitter/ Johnny Vegas

Johnny Vegas, now

But in 2018, he revealed that he'd lost two stone.

Jack Ryder, then30 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Shutterstock

Jack Ryder, then

Jack Ryder, AKA Jamie Mitchell from EastEnders, was a noughties heartthrob if ever there was one.

Jack Ryder, now31 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 BBC Pictures

Jack Ryder, now

In 2018, Jack was announced to be joining Holby City - and look at him now!

Jonathan Tapper, then32 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Tom Cubis

Jonathan Tapper, then

Gogglebox's Jonathan Tapper was 21st 3lbs at his heaviest whilst appearing on the show with his family - wife Nikki, daughter Amy and son Josh.

Jonathan Tapper, now33 of 33
CREDIT: u00a9 Tom Cubis

Jonathan Tapper, now

But with the help of a diet plan, Jonathan was able to lose a whopping three stone in just 12 weeks, and six inches off his waist!

Giles, who has presented Trust Me, I'm A Doctor on the BBC for 20 years told The Daily Mail, "This is a dangerous suggestion, as many people will take it to mean they should be as thin as possible.

"It is irresponsible because the idea is so open to misinterpretation, especially for young girls susceptible to eating disorders.

"The problem with many of Goop's recommendations is that they are not based on science, but pseudoscience."

NOW WATCH: Dove Cameron on 'crying over pasta' at the end of Descendants 3

READ MORE celeb news

Rebekah Vardy returns from Dubai in TEARS amid Coleen Rooney drama

X Factor: Celebrity's Brendan Cole forced to apologise after 'bitchy' comment

Love Island's Maura Higgins FINALLY confirms she's official with Curtis Pritchard

Yet Traci Mann has now hit back at Giles' claims, saying the article is "specifically about not dieting" and "not doing anything unhealthy or extreme".

She adds that "leanest liveable weight" means being your leanest weight without engaging in "strict dieting or unhealthy behaviour."

Gwyneth previously revealed to Shape that she does "one good cleanse a year" to "detox" her body. However, she regularly indulges with "a glass of wine, maybe a baguette dripping in cheese, some fries" and on holiday she will eat "what I want — and there’s no exercising, either”.

Just so you know, we may receive a commission or other compensation from the links on this website - read why you should trust us