THE HEAT X FACTOR SURVEY 2014: THE FULL RESULTS

heat finds out what you all really think of this year's X Factor...

xfactorjudges

by heat staff |
Published on

**1 - Who is the best mentor? **

Simon Cowell 38%

Mel B 37%

Cheryl F-V 22%

Louis Walsh** 3%**

2 - What changes would YOU make to the X Factor judging panel?

Sack Louis Walsh 44%

Sack Cheryl F-V 34%

Sack Mel B 20%

Sack Simon Cowell 2%

**3 - Has Simon’s return improved the show? **

Yes 78%

No** 22%**

**4 - Has Cheryl's return improved the show? **

No 56%

Yes 44%

5 - Who is the most honest judge?

Mel B ** 54%**

Simon Cowell 37%

Cheryl F-V 7%

Louis Walsh 2%

6 - Who is the most boring judge?

Louis Walsh 58%

Cheryl F-V 30%

Mel B 8%

Simon Cowell ** 3%**

**7 - Who is the meanest judge this year? **

Mel B 60%

Simon Cowell 20%

Cheryl F-V 17%

Louis Walsh ** 3%**

8 - Who is the laziest mentor?

Louis Walsh 73%

Cheryl F-V 12%

Mel B 8%

Simon Cowell 7%

9 - If you had to axe one of the female judges, who would you chop?

Cheryl F-V 59%

Mel B 41%

10 - If you had to axe one of the male judges, who would you chop?

Louis Walsh 88%

Simon Cowell 12%

11 - Is the bickering between Simon and Cheryl overshadowing the acts?

Yes 58%

No 42%

12 - Are there too many contestants in the show now the wildcards are on there?

No 55%

Yes 45%

13 - Is Saturday’s show too long?

No 51%

Yes** 49%**

14 - What do you think of the judges song choices?

Too predictable 49%

They’re picking good songs! 23%

Too safe 23%

Too difficult ** 4%**

15 - Which judge picks the best songs?

Simon Cowell 36%

Mel B 32%

Cheryl F-V ** 29%**

Louis Walsh 3%

16 - Which judge chooses the worst songs?

Louis Walsh 76%

Cheryl F-V 15%

Mel B 6%

Simon Cowell 3%

17 - Are you enjoying the choreography?

Some of it 59%

All of it 15%

It’s too much 14%

There’s not enough dancing 12%

18 - Should acts be allowed to sing their own songs?

Yes 79%

No ** 21%**

**19 - What do you think of the show themes? **

Some are ok, others are rubbish ** 52%**

They need to be more modern ** 22%**

I love them 14%

They need to get rid of them 11%

20 - How would you describe this year’s performances, in general?

Average 58%

Incredible 18%

Out of tune 13%

Terrible ** 11%**

21 - Joke acts: is their time over?

Yes 74%

No 26%

22 - Who will win?

Andrea Faustini 47%

Lauren Platt 11%

Fleur East 11%

Paul Akister 9%

Ben Haenow 7%

Jay James 4%

Stereo Kicks 3%

Lola Saunders 3%

Jack Walton 2%

Only The Young 1%

Stevi Richie 1%

23 - Whose album would you genuinely buy?

Andrea Fausini 22%

Fleur East 18%

Lauren Platt 14%

Paul Akister 12%

Ben Haenow ** 8%**

Only The Young** 6%**

Stereo Kicks 6%

Jay James 5%

Jack Walton 5%

Lola Saunders ** 3%**

Stevi Richie 1%

24 - Which show are you enjoying more?

X Factor 70%

Strictly Come Dancing 30%

Just so you know, we may receive a commission or other compensation from the links on this website - read why you should trust us