Love Island producers love to throw a curveball at us, don’t they? Just 24 hours after Ekin-Su Cülcüloğlu strutted into the villa as All Stars 2025’s first bombshell, they shook things up once again by sending Casey O’Gorman in for his THIRD attempt at finding love in just two years.
Naturally, Casey’s comeback sent fans into a meltdown on social media as they rushed to share their opinions, but it wasn’t just viewers that were having their say as his fellow Islanders were also speaking out.
However, things got a bit awkward when Casey’s former flame and All Stars 2024 co-star Georgia Harrison entered the comments section, leading Tom Clare to call her out for being ‘insensitive’.
Referencing her infamous comments about Casey’s grandad that led to him ghosting her (no pun intended), Georgia wrote, ‘Grandad said good luck 🤞,’ under Love Island’s Instagram announcement of Casey’s bombshell entrance.
Tom then replied and wrote, ‘Very insensitive thing to say? He was very close to his grandad.’
Both comments now appear to have been deleted.
Casey’s return to the villa didn’t get off to the best start when Georgia’s close pal Kaz Crossley accused him of being a ‘player’.
‘You’ve been with a lot of Islanders and that’s a red flag,’ Kaz told Casey as all the Islanders gathered around the fire pit.
‘I’ve heard that he’s f**ked over a few girls and obviously, that’s not nice.’
She continued, ‘That’s just the word on the street. That’s why, I’m not saying who, I’m just saying you’re not very nice to girls.’
However, Casey protested his innocence and insisted, ‘But I’ve never f**ked over a girl on the show, I’ve been very straight up.’
The row divided viewers, with some saying Kaz ‘came on too strong’, while others insisted she was just being a ‘girl’s girl’.
WATCH Love Island winner Mimii Tafara transforms into Beyoncé for heat's Stars Dress Up
Nathan Katnoria is heat and Closer online’s senior digital writer. He became obsessed with Love Island when Malin Andersson came back to confront Terry Walsh in series two and hasn’t looked back since. When he’s not interviewing former Islanders, Nathan is scrolling through their Instagram feeds for relationship updates and piping hot tea.