‘Controversial’ UK star joins Love Island Games after ‘soulmate cheats on him’

He and Lucinda Strafford will have a lot to talk about

Love Island cast
@ITV

by Emily Vierke |
Updated on

Somebody best check on Love Island veteran Casey O'Gorman.

Not only has his Love Island title of taking part in the most seasons been nabbed by Toby Aromolaran, but because we haven't heard from him much since Tom Clare announced his engagement to Molly Smith.

We are concerned. Actually, no we're not – he's probably in holding for Love Island Games, let's be honest.

Toby
Toby ©Peacock

Love Island 2021 finalist Toby has returned to the dating show for a FOURTH time after failing to find The One on All Stars in 2024.

Toby has joined bestie and footballer friend Tyrique Hyde on the second series of Love Island Games as a bombshell and it's almost enough to make us tune in.

He originally took part in season seven where he met Chloe Burrows; the duo finished in second place and continued to date outside of the villa before splitting after a year. Toby took part in the first series of Love Island Games in 2023 where he struck up a romance with Georgia Steel, a romance that was revisited during All Stars series one. However, it was far from a match made in heaven and the duo had a rather public and dare we say, toxic, split?

Georgia and Toby
Georgia and Toby ©©ITV

It was during his stint on All Stars that Toby dropped major hints – during a chat with Anton Danyluk – that Chloe had cheated on him.

'It hurts to get cheated on. With that girl. She was it,' he told his villa mate, 'I was happy. Soulmates vibes.'

Although he didn't name Chloe, it didn't take a rocket scientist to work out who he was chatting about.

When the episode aired, Chloe indirectly responded to the accusation with a bikini selfie and a caption that read, 'Everything Gucci xx.'

Love Island Chloe Toby
©ITV Pictures

An iconic response, tbh.

Chloe is currently in a new relationship with Ruben Moreira, so we can't imagine she will be taking part in The Games anytime soon but that doesn't mean to say her name won't pop up at some point especially seeing as Lucinda Strafford is also on the show...

WATCH : Luca Bish and Grace Jackson are the last remaining couple from All Stars 2025 so we'll be listening to any advice they give 😂

Emily Vierke is a digital writer who has dabbled in the world of celeb, beauty and fashion. She enjoys stalking Love Island girlies Indiyah Polack and Matilda Draper for outfit inspo nearly as much as she enjoys rewatching the clip of Maura Higgins confronting Tom Walker for gossiping about her to the Love Island lads.

Just so you know, we may receive a commission or other compensation from the links on this website - read why you should trust us